Top 10 Best Cordless Orbital Sander Tools for Smooth Finishes

Comparing the Makita and DeWalt Orbital Sanders

In this article, we will put two popular orbital sanders to the test: the Makita 18-volt (XOB01) and the DeWalt 20-volt (DCW210). Both are 5-inch random orbit sanders, and we will compare their performance, ergonomics, and overall convenience based on real-life usage in the field.

Performance: Dust Collection and Sanding Efficiency

From the tests we conducted, it became evident that the Makita sander has superior dust collection compared to the DeWalt. The Makita’s bag was emptied more frequently, while the DeWalt’s was barely a quarter full after running for the same amount of time. The Makita also produced less sawdust around the working area.

As for sanding efficiency, we found that both sanders have comparable results in terms of smoothness after sanding for 30 seconds. However, we did not find any substantial evidence that one sander was significantly faster than the other.

Ergonomics and Ease of Use

When comparing the ergonomics of these two sanders, the Makita’s height may be an issue for some users who prefer a lower-profile palm sander. On the other hand, the DeWalt’s compact design feels excellent in hand without the battery attached. However, attaching the battery makes the sander quite back-heavy, which may cause user fatigue. Thus, the Makita’s design and balance may be preferred by some users.

Both sanders offer different methods of holding and gripping, but the Makita offers more flexibility with its front grip design, allowing users to hold it like a traditional palm sander. The DeWalt’s switch can be difficult to toggle compared to the Makita’s electric button, which could affect long-term reliability.

A unique feature of the DeWalt sander is its built-in brake, which stops the sander almost instantly. This feature is absent in the Makita sander and is quite a handy convenience.

Comparing Speed Adjustments

The DeWalt sander offers a handy speed adjustment dial, which some users may find more accessible compared to the Makita’s button system. However, left-handed users might unintentionally alter the speed setting on the DeWalt sander due to its dial placement.

Overall Convenience and Storage

In terms of storage and the footprint of the sanders, the Makita has a clear advantage. Its size allows for much better storage in tight spaces, such as in a tool bag or a van. The DeWalt’s protruding dust bag may cause some issues with storage, and its size may take up more space compared to two Makita sanders positioned beside each other.

The Makita’s battery and dustbag placement are both more convenient than the DeWalt’s design, which requires bending down and exerting extra effort to remove the battery. Furthermore, the DeWalt’s hard dust port could potentially be damaged if accidentally stepped on, whereas the Makita’s is made of flexible rubber and is less likely to break.

Conclusion

In conclusion, both the Makita and DeWalt orbital sanders perform well in terms of sanding efficiency. However, the Makita edges out the DeWalt in terms of dust collection, ergonomics, and convenience. The DeWalt does offer advantages such as its built-in brake and accessible speed adjustment dial, but these may not outweigh the overall comfort and ease-of-use benefits seen in the Makita.

Ultimately, the choice between the two sanders comes down to personal preference and specific use cases. For users who value a compact storage footprint and versatile design, the Makita may be the more suitable option. On the other hand, those who prefer a lower profile and the handy brake feature may lean towards the DeWalt.

It is important to note that both sanders are products from reputable brands, and you cannot go wrong with either choice. Each has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, and the ideal sander for you depends on your unique needs and preferences.